Quantcast

Obama's Former Law School Mentor Says The President Is Burning The Constitution

Surprisingly, President Obama’s law school mentor, Laurence Tribe, testified before Congress this week that “burning the Constitution of the United States, about which I care deeply, cannot be a part of our national energy policy.” He said that the “EPA is attempting an unconstitutional trifecta: usurping the prerogatives of the States, Congress and the Federal Courts — all at once.”

On Tuesday, the House Energy and Commerce committee's Energy and Power subcommittee held a hearing concerning the "legal and cost issues" surrounding the EPA's proposed 111(d) Rule for Existing Power Plants. Tribe was referring to the President's plan to clean up power plant carbon pollution using a section of the Clean Air Act. It will get another hearing in the U.S. District Court of Appeals on April 14 after challenges came forth from the coal industry. Tribe also said, “When I use the metaphor that burning the Constitution is not a good source of fuel for dealing with these problems, I was being metaphorical only in part,” he said. “When you tear the Constitution apart, bit by bit, and give it the death by a thousand cuts, what else will we sacrifice the Constitution for?”

On the other hand, Richard L. Revesz, the Lawrence King Professor of Law and Dean Emeritus at the New York University School of Law said, “The Clean Power Plan is not, as its opponents argue, an unprecedented approach that risks economic calamity. Instead, it is just another example of the EPA doing its job to ensure that polluters account for the cost of their pollution in a manner that will result in substantial net economic benefits to the public.” Under the Clean Air Act, the EPA is required to regulate greenhouse gases. Tribe talked about the conflict over whether the Clean Air Act lets the EPA go after emissions "inside" or "outside the fence." Meaning whether or not the EPA can allow states to limit carbon from coal plants by using more renewable energy is what is called "outside the fence." Tribe says the EPA's use of outer-fence-tactics would be a "radical change."

Photo: Grist

Tell Us What You Think

More News Stories

Many women in their reproductive years suffer from polycystic ovary syndrome, also known as PCOS, and that can lead to cysts forming directly on...

A Philadelphia, Pennsylvania neighborhood is being invaded by thousands of unwelcome guests. According to locals in the Bridesburg section, on...

A math puzzle being circulated on social media is stumping a lot of adults. Kids seem to figure it out easily. Can you crack the code?

Talk...

On Monday, presidential front-runner Donald Trump blamed a bad earpiece over a misunderstanding of white nationalist David Duke's support.

...

Everyone loves a bargain, so you might jump on it if you see a bag of rice for a good price. According to some Asian news sources, however, you...

Latest News Stories

Rosie O'Donnell still has an extremely sour taste in her mouth about President Donald Trump's win. She blew up at the president when he responded...

A man in Memphis, Tennessee came across a couple passed out on the sidewalk. The man stopped his car and pulled out his phone, but instead of...

Your daughters, sisters, wives, mothers, female friends. One out of three of them will have experienced physical or sexual violence in their...

Ann Coulter lashed out at the news media in a recent interview, arguing that Donald Trump’s refusal to pay taxes is getting too much coverage....

The seemingly never-ending feud between Rosie O’Donnell and President-elect Donald Trump has reemerged into the spotlight after the star took it...